iSearchNotes is a FREE service that allows College Students to
Search and Share Class Notes.
Website information at http://philosophy.tamucc.edu/readings/professional-ethics/handouts/arguments
The Benefits Argument (from Rachels)
- If we can benefit someone without harming others, we ought to.
- Removing Baby Theresa's organs and transplanting them would benefit other babies without harming Baby Theresa.
- Baby Theresa's organs ought to have been removed and transplanted.
The Wrongness of Killing Argument (from Rachels)
- It is wrong to kill one person to save another.
- Removing Baby Theresa's organs and transplanting them would have involved killing one person to save another.
- It would have been wrong to remove Baby Theresa's organs and transplant them.
2 Key features of morality -
- Rationality : The right thing to do is the one supported by the best reasons.
- Impartiality : Considering the interests of everyone involved without being biased or prejudice. or NOT giving preference to a group or individual without a good reason.


